Monday, 27 October 2014

Thoughts on the recent Abortion and Disability Debate - Ann Furedi & James Mumford

The abortion of those with a disability has been the subject of much media debate in recent months. You can listen to a debate on the topic between the head of  BPAS Ann Furedi and Ethicist James Mumford, the debate is based on recent tweet's from Richard Dawkin's.

I just had a few observations related to the debate and the philosophical basis for Dawkin's comments to "abort it and try again".

1. If the abortion of disabled fetuses is an affront to the dignity of those born with a disability then the abortion of a fetus without a disability ought to be an affront to the dignity of those without a disability.

2. Dawkin's comment about replacing a disabled fetus with a healthy one is not something he came up with himself, his views are based on Peter Singer's controversial replaceability principle in his book 'Practical Ethics'. What this entails is applying utilitarian ethical principles to the problem of fetal disability. Utilitarianism intends to minimize suffering and maximizing happiness, therefore, in the event of fetal disability the mother using utilitarian reasoning ought to kill the disabled fetus and replace them with a healthy one. This is because the death of the disabled fetus results in no future suffering for them and it maximizes happiness/pleasure through bringing a healthy infant into the world.

3. A few problems with the replaceability principle are that it assumes the total suffering of the disabled life will be greater than the healthy one. However, this cannot be definitively known, what if the 'healthy' fetus grows up to be a murderer/rapist/robber etc, or grows up to be a manic depressive who hates living but cannot bring about ending their life. There are numerous cases where the life of someone without a disability does not guarantee producing greater happiness on the utilitarian calculus. The replacement principle simply begs the question by assuming that the life of someone without a disability will de facto be a happier life than someone with a disability when this simply cannot always be the case. In fact numerous studies have observed that those living with a disability are as happy or happier than their counterparts with no disability.

How can the person intending to replace the disabled fetus know that their next attempt at conceiving will actually bring about a healthy fetus and not another disabled fetus? If this were the case the the suffering from a utilitarian perspective is immediately doubled, the parents must go through another abortion, knowing they are responsible for another death. Why must the disabled fetus be replaced with another one, why not a dog? Providing they were well looked after and not disabled? As long as the act brings about happier consequences then all is good and well.

4. The replaceability principle is eugenic, it supports and helps propagate the idea that humans must meet arbitrary standards of normalcy before they can be welcomed into the world. If you cannot see how this is eugenic, you don't understand eugenics.

5. The eugenic basis of the replaceability principle helps to subvert the maternal-child relationship into one which is conditional and tentative. Rather than accepting ones offspring for who they are, they may only be permitted to live should they meet certain requirements and not use more than their fair share of societies resources.

Originally posted at Mind the Evangelical.


    See jokes video at a big collection of jokes video submitted by world wide people and our great comedians. top collection of really funny jokes video. 100+ Joke Categories with tons of funny jokes video funny Insults

  2. Social Networks these days are becoming vital part of our lives. Although Facebook rules in social networking but there are several others growing significantly. is one of them with a totally different idea. is up with an idea to share 90% of its revenue it will earn with your activities. If you have a 100 Friends at, then you can earn $2 to $3 daily which turns out to be $70 per month, click here

  3. Articles and content in this section of the website are really amazing. Great ideas indeed! I will surely keep this in my mind!

    Angry Status For Whatsapp & funnyvideo

  4. Salam Damai Sahabatku,
    Blog yang sangat menarik, senang berkunjung di sini, Thanks.
    kunjungi juga :
    Jual Pipa Stainless,
    jual hollow stainless,
    jual strip stainless

  5. Hey admin, your blog's design is so cool and loving it. Your articles are so cool. Please continue this great work. Greets!!!

    Affordable seo Services India & Best SEO Services India

  6. They Looks fabulous. Beautiful words u have sheared in your article.

    Direct Mail Marketing Services & Direct Mail Letter Services

  7. When you're tired, you want to relax after a stressful working hours, you need to have time to take care of the kids active.
    Please visit our website and play exciting flash games.
    Thanks you for sharing!
    Friv 4

  8. I would like more information about this, because it is very nice., Thanks for sharing.


  9. I was very impressed by this post, this site has always been pleasant news. Thank you very much for such an interesting post. Keep working, great job! In my free time, I like play game: What about you?

  10. Wow! this is Amazing! Do you know your hidden name meaning ? Click here to find your hidden name meaning

  11. You should participate in a contest for probably the greatest blogs on the web. I will recommend this site! There are so many fun and exciting things to do and experience around the world that I thought I'd put together a list of my favourite Things to do for all travelers ...


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...